"You Thought Wrong"
Éneklik: Kelly Clarkson & Tamyra Gray
Dalszöveg: Harvey Mason, Jr./Damon Thomas/Kenneth Edmonds/Kelly Clarkson/Tamyra Gray

Tamyra:
I see how you're tryin' to
Weasel your way and boy I
Know how you manuever
With your, your confusion.

Kelly:
You tell me that I'm your only
And how bad that you want me
Then why are you so shady?
If I'm supposed to be your lady

Tamyra:
Why should I believe?
Anything you say
And how could you shame me that way?

Kelly:
Tell me where
Where'd you get the nerve
To even think that you,
You could play me, boy?

Both:
You thought we didn't know
You thought we were in the dark
But boy your cover's blown
'Cause we both know now
You thought you had us both
At your beckon call
But now who's the joke?
And look who's laughin' now

Kelly:
Now you're tryin' to use us, a

Tamyra:
Against one another but it won't work

Kelly:
I see right through your game, boy

Tamyra:
And I know exactly what I blame for

Both:
You

Kelly:
You try to deny all your actions

Tamyra:
For once in your life be a real man

Kelly:
At least give me the proper respect of

Both:
The truth I already know you did it

Kelly:
Why should I believe?
Anything you say
And how could you shame me
That way?

Tamyra:
Tell me where
Where'd you get the nerve
To even think that you,
You could play me, boy?

Both:
You thought we didn't know
You thought we were in the dark
But boy you're cover's blown
'Cause we both know now
You thought you had us both
At your beckon call
But now who's the joke?
And look who's laughin' now

I see right through you, baby
Tried to tell me you want me
Can't you just get it through your
Get it through your thick thick thick thick head?

'Cause I've seen this game before and
I'm showin' you the door so
Shut your mouth
I'm not tryin' to hear your lies no, not again

Oh...

Tamyra:
Oh no, not again

Kelly:
Sorry you couldn't be a better man

Tamyra:
Oh...

Both:
No no no no no

Both:
You thought we didn't know
You thought we were in the dark
But boy your cover's blown
'Cause we both know now
You thought you had us both
At your beckon call
But now who's the joke?
And look who's laughin' now

Kelly:
Guess you thought wrong

Tamyra:
Look who's laughing now.

(Laughter)

Kelly:
So stupid

(Laughter)